Weight deviation testing device



Dec. 29, 1953 J. A. SARGROVE 2,664,557

WEIGHT DEVIATION TESTING DEVICE Filed June 20, 1952 4 Sheets-Sheet l PS HIGH coumen P,S Loy 67 66' 7'? TIME user Hfiol Inventor B l cmma w Attorneys Dec. 29, 1953 J, SARGROVE 2,664,557

WEIGHT DEVIATION TESTING DEVICE Filed June -20, 1952 /7 JO 2. E

4 Sheets-Sheet 2 1953 J. A. SARGROVE 2,664,557

WEIGHT DEVIATION TESTING DEVICE Fi led June 20, 1952 4 Sheets-Sheet 5 Patented Dec. 29, 1953 WEIGHT DEVIATION TESTING DEVICE John Adolph Sargrove, Shepperton-on-Thames,

England, assignor to Sargrove Electronics Limited, London, England, a British company Application June 2t, 1952, Serial N 0. 294,760

Claims priority, application Great Britain June 20, 1951 8 Claims. (Cl. 340--213) This invention relates to control or indicating systems which may be 0.; the electrically, pneumatically or hydraulically operated kind, but the invention be anplied also to purely mechanical control systems.

In the production of large quantities of articles which have one characteristic or property which is the same from article to article, it is very often required to test the articles in respect of that characteristic as t ey are produced and to provide an indication or a control function in response to which the manufacture of the ar ti les can be controlled to maintain the characteristic at a predetermined value. For example, it may be required to produce articles which have a similar physical dimension or which have an e1 ctrical property such as resistance or oapacitance which is the same from article to article; or again it may be desired. to produce articles of constant weight. Purely for the sake of conven ence, the present invention will hereinafter be described in relation to the production of articles of constant weight, but it will be understood that the invention can be applied to the control of manufacture to produce other constant physical characteristics in the articles produoed.

In the past, many processes have been used for the production of articles oi, for example, constant weight, and suggestions have been made of processes by which the weight of the articles thus produced is ascertained and is used to give an indication or control function by which the weight of the articles as produced is or can be varied. in the simplest and most obvious of these processes each article, or samples, are weighed; if the article weighs more than a certain amount, the machine is adjusted to reduce the weight of the subsequent articles produced, while if the'article weighs below a certain amount the weight of the subsequent articles is increased.

In the manufacture of any article, there must inevitably be a tolerance. For example, in menu featuring articles which are required to be of a predetermined weight, the articles can never be produced to be all of exactly the same weight, and at best it can be ensured that the weight of every article will be between an upper and a lower limit.

Still using weight control as an example, the weights of articles produced will all lie within an upper and a lower weight, and the value of these weights will depend on all the factors which contribute to weight variations in addition to the setting of that part of the machine which nominally controls the weight of the articles. If

' those which depart excessively in the ctl: r

2 the predetermined limits within which the ar tlcles must. lie are equal to or less than the up per and lower weights which the machine will produce for a given setting of the weight-controlling part of the machine, the automatic adjus ment of that control is a simple matter, since requires no more than that should an article, as produced, weigh more than the predetermined amount an immediate change of the setting can be effectec in a correcting sense.

This condition is, however, rarely met in pram tics, and it is almost invariably the case desired upper and lower limits represent tolerances, or deviations from a mean value, which are less than the extreme deviations to be expected. Some articles must, in fact, be rejected; the pro portion of articles rejected to those passed will depend upon the acceptable limits in relation to the normal deviations.

In such circumstances, automatic control of the setting of the machine in response to the weight (or other) deviation of the articles is much more diflicult, since if the weight of an article lies outside the prescribed limits th re is no means knowing whether it is one of the statistically occurring rejects, or whether its excessive deviation is due to some change of conditions in the machine or elsewhere which warrant a change of adjustment of the machine.

The present invention has for its object to provide an arrangement for securing an adjustment of the setting means of a machine of the type described which more nearly follows the optimum value. The invention is based upon an ape eclation of the fact that if the machine is run: in the best possible setting of the control th 11 by the laws of statistical distribution the number of reject articles which fall above the upper acceptable limit will bear a known relation to number which fell below the lower limit. In most cases the numbers will be the same, that is, of the inevitable rejects as many will be acted because they are too big as are rejected because they are too small. It the acceptable limits brought closer together, the proportion of rej s will increase (which can be statistically predict ed) but this relation will still hold.

In accordance with the broadest aspect of the invention, in a machine of the type specifies, means are provided for measuring the property of the article or pro-duct, or of detecting the dc parture of the value of that property from a predetermined value, and means are provided for comparing the number of articles v de excessively from the said value in one sens Et norm O1 T119211.

3 and means are provided for effecting an adjustment of the machine in accordance with a change, over a period, of the results of comparison.

In a simple arrangement. according to the invention there can be used a weightdeviation detecting device of any suitable type which is capable of detecting weight deviations above and below a predetermined value. When an article is found to have a weight which exceeds an upper limit, a Voltage output is produced which is led to a counting device. The nature of-this counting depends upon thespeed or" operation; iorlow speeds an electromagnetic type of counter can be used, whilst for higher speeds an electronic type of counting circuit'can'be used. In the latter case, the output voltage may be first shaped and passed-through an amplitude limiter. It is convenient, but not necessary, that the counter should give an indication of the number of pulses received.

A similar output voltage is obtained from the weighing means when an under-weight article is detected, and these voltages are fed to the same counting device, but so as to reduce the count each time; at any time, therefore, the count will represent the difference in number between overweight and under-weight articles.

When this diiierence attains a predetermined positive or negative value the weight adjusting means of the machine is actuated in the appropriate sense, and the counter is reset to zero.

It is highly advantageous if different weight deviations are set i r effecting control and for effecting rejection. In such an arrangement the weights (Or corresponding characteristic) of the articles or samples of the articles are ascertained and these weights are graded. An upper and a lower limit is set, outside which limits the article weight will be rejected. Within these limits two further limits are set up. If the weight of the article falls within the innermost of these limits, then no action will be taken either to reject the article or to make any effect in relation to a control function, that is, it will tend to maintain the status quo. f the weight of the article falls outside these innermost limits, but still within the rejection limits, an effect is produced which tends to produce a change in th indication or in the control function. If the weight or" the article falls outside the rejection limits, this same effect is produced, but in addition the particular individual article is rejected.

An article falling outside the rejection can be arranged to produce an effect, so far as indication or control is concerned, which is of the same magnitude or a greater magnitude than an article falling within the intermediate limits.

It has already been mentioned that with articles produced by any process, whether manual or mechanical, they will almost invariably show a truly statistical distribution of deviation from in the case of weight, for example, it will always occur that there will be a small proportion of articles produced which show a large weight deviation above or below the norm,

whilst a larger number of articles will show a lesser deviation. The few, large variations will include the reject articles, and the outer reject limits can be set as desired. It the'inner limits are appropriately set, the articles falling between these limits are those which are closeto the average figure, and which will be most numerous when the machine is operating correctly. So

long as this condition obtains, there. will be, in

41 general, an equal number of articles above and below these limits; in accordance with one ieature of the invention, so long as these numbers are approximately equal over a given period of time, or for a given number of articles, no change is made in the indication or the control lunction. Should the weight of an article fall outside the outermost limits, that article is rejected, but the fact that one article has been rejected does not of itself result in a control function being carried out. Thus, the present invention makes possible the derivation of a control function which follows theinean of the weights of the articles and which is, not disproportionately ariected by the articles of wide deviation which will inevitably occur, and in which to a large extent the control function or control operation follows a statistical law.

With the apparatus of the invent on it can also be arranged that at any moment the shoot of the most recently weighed articles is greater than that of less recently weighed In practice, if over a period of time the net result ofthe weighings is that the heavy articles five in number more than the light, and then five light articles arrive in succession, the latter iact,

though it may be more s atistical chance, is more likely to be due to some factor, such as a change of density, or a change the mechanism warranting an adjustment. With the invention, by making the latest weighings of more importance the system is l iade more sensitive to further light wei hinge and-the system will therefore respond to conditions warranting a change of the control function more rapidly than otherwisewould be the case.

In some special circumstances, the statistical distribution of deviation may not be, or may not be desired to be, equally above and below the norm; in that case the limits can be set accordingly, on the effect of under or overweights on the control function can be dissimilar.

By way of example, embodiments of the invention will now be described, in coniunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:

Figure l is block schematic diagram or a simple arrangement in accordance with th invention.

Figure 2 is a diagram showing the mechanical arrangement of a weighing device incorporating the invention.

Figure 3 is a simplified circ tit diagram o t' e apparatus associated with the weighing vic of Figure 2.

Figure 4 is a diagrammatic sketch of a counting or registering device which can be used.

Figure 5 is a diagrammatic sleet-ch or" a modified photoelectric arrangement of the weighing means.

Figure 6 is a fragmentary and partly blo k diagram of a suitable photocell amplifier.

Figure '7 is a circuit diagram or" an electronic registering device, and

Figure 8 is a circuit diagram of a timing unit associated with the circuit of Figure '7.

In Figure 1 the unit 553 is a moulding unit of known type for separating from a mass of material such as'dough portions 59 of nominally constant weight. l'he volume of the portions is adjustable by means of a controlmeinber 5!. In the known type of machine this is a handwheel, but for the purpose of the present invention the hand-wheel is replaced by a pinion drivable by a worm 52 on the shaft of a reversible electric motor 53. The effect of moving the control members 5! is to move one wall of a moulding chamber and thereby to vary the volume of the delivered portions.

The articles [9 fall upon a conveyor 54, and at the end of the conveyor they pass over a guide 55 and to the scale pan l8 of a weight deviation monitor 55. This unit rapidly determines whether the articles are over or under weight, within the predetermined limits and produces outputs on terminals or 58 respectively if they are. When the article has been weighed the scale pan is released and the article falls into a guideway 63; the article may pass to an accept" or reject outlet fil or 62 in accordance with the setting of a guide flap 63 actuated by a device, such as a solenoid 64.

The outputs at terminals 51 or 58 are fed to a counter 65, through shaping networks 66, 61, which merely produce appropriate input voltages or pulses for the counter. The counter is such as to maintain an arithmetic count of the diiference in number of the pulses which are applied to its two inputs; that is to say it will give a continuous record of the excess of the number of articles of overweight articles over underweight articles, or vice versa. The counter also includes means for producing an output when the number of overweight articles exceeds that of the underweight articles by a predetermined number, and an output when the number of underweight articles exceeds that of the overweight articles by a predetermined number which may or may not be equal to the other predetermined number. These outputs are fed respectively to a high control unit ill and a low control unit 1 I, which energise, and determine the direction of rotation of, the reversible correcting motor 53. In addition, these control units control a reset unit 72 for the counter, restoring its effective count to zero. The reset unit 12 can also be reset by a timing unit l3, after a given time interval. The control units 16 and H also start the timing interval after each correction of the moulding.

The reject device 64 can be arranged to be operated by one or both of the outputs of the weight deviation monitor at 57 or 58.

A form of construction of weight deviation monitor which has been found satisfactory in practice is shown diagrammatically in Figure 2 and the associated electrical circuit is shown in Figure 3. The arrangements shown in these two figures of the drawings do not form per se part of this present invention.

In this weight monitor the scale pan I8, to which the articles are delivered from conveyor 54 is carried by a balance arm; this arm is held locked whilst the article is transferred to the weighing monitor, thereafter the arm is freed. If the portion is exactly equal in weight to the predetermined amount no motion of the balance arm results, but if there is a deviation from this amount the balance arm will move with an acceleration which is proportional to the value of the deviation. Means are then provided to respond to this acceleration, and also to the direction of motion of the arm.

The weighing apparatus comprises a parallel link structure consisting of two horizontal links it and H, and two vertical joining links H! and 3. These links are pivoted together by low friction bearings at M, and the two links and i l are pivoted at their mid-points at l5 to a supporting standard Hi. In practice, for rigidity, two such parallel link structures spaced apart are used, the corresponding members I0 and members i i being securely fixed together by spacing members, but for simplicity these are not shown in Figure 1.

The link 12 carries a balance weight ll, which can be changed as necessary, and link l3 supports the pan I8 for an article 59 to be weighed. The pan is supported from link l3 by an arm 20, pivoted at 2| and spring biased so that when no article is upon the pan the arm will move to engage a stop 22. It can be retained in this posi-- tion by a latching lever 23, pivoted at 24 to the link 13. The latching lever is also lightly springbiased to the latching position, but can be moved by the armature of a tip solenoid 25 to free the arm 29 and permit the pan to tip. Normally there is no contact between the armature of the solenoid and the tail of the latching lever.

Associated with the arm 12 is a locking and centering mechanism. A lug 26 is fixed to the arm and is adapted to enter a slot in a locking arm 21, pivoted at 28 to a stationary part of the apparatus and biased by spring 29 to engage the lug. The arm can be moved to free it from the lug by a release solenoid 30. The centering mechanism comprises a centering arm 3 I, pivoted at 32 to a stationary part of the apparatus, and biased by a spring 33. This arm has on one face a detent, adapted to engage a pin 34 on the link 12. The edges of the detent are inclined so that under the spring loading the arm will pull in the balance arm accurately to a datum position. Beneath the balance arm is arranged a center" solenoid 35, the armature of which when actu ated in the direction of the arrow moves the locking arm against the spring loading and thus frees the balance arm.

A photoelectric system not shown, including a light source and a photosensitive cell, is provided for the purpose of detecting when an article is in position on the pan.

Associated with the link ill are adjustable contacts 36 and 31, actuated when the arm has travelled a given amount from the mid, locked position, and adjustable stops 33, 39 are provided to limit the movement of the balance mechanism.

In Figure 3 is shown the simplified circuit di agram of a control device which is provided to respond to the photoelectric system, so as to actuate the balance arm releasing solenoid when an article has been placed upon the pan and has come to rest. When the balance arm is thus released the only force which will be applied to it will be the out of balance force due to the weight deviation of the article under test. If the weight of the article is exactly equal to the nominal weight the balance arm will not move. If however, the article is heavier than the nominal value the pan end of the balance arm will move downwardly with an acceleration which is proportional to the deviation of weight of the article.

The balance arm will thus move to close one set of contacts 36 or 3?, and the time taken to actuate the contacts will likewise be proportional to the weight deviation of the article. It follows that with any given arrangement of parts and setting of the contacts, a weight deviation which represents the maximum permissible deviation will cause the contacts to close at the end of a certain time interval; if the contacts are actuated before that time interval the deviation exceeds the permissibl value.

The control means is therefore arranged to re spond to the actuation of the contacts and includes timing means by whi h can distinguish by the photocell whether or not the actuation of the contacts occurs within a given time interval after the -operation of the balance" armreleasing solehold. The control means is arranged to distuated within the predetermined time interval;

It is therei re preferred to arrange that the control circuit responds to the first actuation only of the contacts.

Means are also provided for adjusting the maximum deviation values which the control means can distinguish. This can be 'done by variation of the adjustment of the contacts on the balance arm, but as these contacts are normally somewhat inaccessible it is preferred to make the adjustment by variation of the timing interval in the control means. In any case, after the timing interval has elapsed the latch release solenoid is operated by the control means and the portion is discharged from the pan.

Turning now to Figure 3, this circuit includes a settle timer tube V1. At the'b'eginning of the cycle of operation the anode circuit ofthis tube is interrupted at contacts PCB-when an article is deposited upon the pan and is detected the contacts PCl close.

' 'Tube V1 includes a resistor R1 and a relay 8/ 1- in its cathode circuit; the grid-cathcdecircuit includes a and an adjustable 'resist'onR-z and'Bn, and the grid is connectedth'rough'the contacts S1 of relay S and a capacitor G1 to ground.

.At the instant when contacts PC! close, the two terminals of capacitor G1 are at the same potential Plate current begins to iiow in the tube, but

positive; bec use of capacitor (lithe grid cannot immediately follow this potential rise 'of the though connected to it through resistors and R3,. but only at an exponential rate determined by the time constant of the circuit through which G1 charges. Hence, after a time interval, adjustable by resistor R3, the plate'current' will reach a value when relay S/Ll operates. Contests 51 change over, and capacitor G1 is discharged trough a small current limiting resistor R4. Relay contact S1 thereby remains operated until contacts POI open again. Contacts S: are in s "ies with the winding RS of the release sole d. 36. Contacts S3 are included in the anode ci.

ult of two tubes V2 and V3, which are arranged .Lfl. timing circuits similar to that of tube V1, and will not therefore be further described. lube V2 includes relay W/3 in its cathode circuit, shunted by a capacitor G2; the changeover contacts W1 of'this relay are in the grid circ it oi tube V2, the contacts We are inelude in series with the winding TS of the tip solen and the normally" closed contacts We re in series with thewindings' CS of the r. s ncid At the instant t at relay s s operates, as described above, the center solenoid winding CS is energised. over contacts W3, so that when the release solenoid winding RS is energised-over contacts the balance is free to move in accordance with the weight of the article i 9 on the pan.

For the moment it will be assumed that the article is of exact weight, and no movement of the takes. place. Both tubes V2 and: V3 begin to draw current and after time clelays'the -relays W/3 and C/Zlin their' cathode circuits will operate. Tube V2 time delay is used to deter- -mine the weighing time; tube Va'time-delay de termines the correction timawhichwill be referred to further below.

-At the end of the weighing time relay W/S operates; contacts Wropen inthe timing circuit the article falls from the tilted pan. The-center solenoid, now (is-energised, permits the centering lever 35 to move under the tension of this tends to make the cathode more spring 3% balance.

At the end of the timing period of tube V3 to center thelink i2 andwith itthe relay 0/2 operates and contacts C2 which are included in a correction circuit, open.

When the article has been tippecl from the pan, the photocell detector again has light incident upon it, the contacts PCI open. Relay S/ l releases, contacts S2 open and relays W/3 and 0/2 also release. The locking lever locks the link 52 in position; after ashort interval due to the capacitor which shunts the relay 'W/3,

contacts W3 close andthe centering arm 3| is disengaged from pin 35. No further action takes place until the next article is perceived.

"Tubes V4 and V5 are the tubes which are used for responding to the balance contacts 35, 31. The cathodes of these two valves are grounded,

and the grids are returned throughresistors R5,

R7 and Rs to a point of negative potential which is shown as being the negative terminal of the supply for the solenoids; a bypass capacitor G4 is included. The plate circuits of the tubes in-.

clude respectivelythe high relay H/3- and the low relay L/ii, and thecontacts L1 and H1 of those relays; bothplate circuits of both tubes include contacts S4'Of relay S/ i. Contacts H2 of relay H/3 are arranged betweengrid and cathode of tube V4, and contacts L2 oi-relay L/ 3 between grid and cathode of tubeVs. Contacts 33 and 3? when closed are arranged to connect ,thegrids of valves V5 and Vito ground.

When the settle relay S/ l operates at-the-end of the settling time, contacts S4 close, and'applies plate voltage to the two tubes-V4 and V5. Contacts 3t and 3'! and H2 and L; are allopen, and so the grids of the tubes are negative withrespect to the cathodesrthe anode currents are both virtually zero, and relays L/3 and-H/3 are unenergised.

' will open and no further change takes place.

If, however, the article is sufficiently heavy, contacts Slwillclose; the grid of tube V4 is then at the same potential as the cathode and sub- .stantial plate current-flowsin the tube. Relay H/Zi operates; its contacts Hr'open in the circuit of tube V5, thus rendering that tube inoperative,

and 'contactsilz close in parallel with contacts 3'5. In this way the two tubes respondtothe first closure of contacts 36 or 31 and do not respond to any further closure of thosecontacts crates instead of H/3, and tube V4 is rendered ineffective.

The correction circuit is eifected through contacts C2 and either He or L3. Since contacts C2 are normally closed, the correction circuit will be operative only while relay C/2 is closed only until the end of the timing period of tube V3. The correction circuit corresponds to the outputs at terminals 5? and 58 of Figure 1.

It will be seen from the preceding description that the correction circuits are closed for a varying period of time, but this is not necessary for the purpose of the present invention. If desired, tube V3 and its immediately associated parts can be dispensed with.

The counter 55 can be of either the electromechanical kind, or it can be electronic. A sim le form of electromechanical counter is shown diagrammatically in Figure 4. This comprises a ratchet wheel ill on a shaft 8! which can be driven in the anticlockwise direction by a pawl 82 moved by the armature 83 of a relaytype solenoid 84. Ratchet wheel 80 carries a pin 85 which is adapted to engage a spring contact 86 when the wheel has been advanced a given number of tooth positions.

On the same shaft 8! is a second, similar ratchet wheel 8'! but which can be driven in clockwise direction by pawl 8% moved by the armature 89 of solenoid 9U. Rat het wheel 8? carries a pin 9| which is adapted to engage a spring contact 92 when the wheel has been advanced a given number of tooth positions. Contacts 8t and $32 can both be adiusted in position round the ratchet wheels so as to vary the numbers of tooth positions that the wheels have to be advanced before they are engaged by pins 85 or ill.

It w ll be seen that as pulses of current are ap lied to the sol noids 8 and 9" from the ulse sha ers 68 and 61 (which in this case will be required to deliver short current pulses sufiicient only to cause the solenoids to operate) the ratchet wheels will be moved in one direction or the other till contacts 86 or 92 are operated. These contacts are connected to units 70 or H, thereby to cause the correction motor 53 to be ene g sed for a short, predetermined time.

The ratchet wheels can be reset by energising one of the solenoids until pin 85 opens a pair of contacts s3, under the control of the reset unit l2.

The unit t5 can be of the purely electronic type, in which case known types of electronic counter circuits can be used; circuits of the binary type, or those employing multi-cathode discharge tubes, and operated in a decimal or a binary-decimal system can be employed. Alternatively, and in a manner which is similar to device described hereinafter, on each input from unit 56 a small capacitor, charged to a high voltage, is connected to a much larger capacitor. A similar small capacitor, but oppositely charged, is connected to the larger capacitor when there is input from unit 6?. Hence, at any moment the charge on the capacitor is a function of the arithmetic sum of the number of inputs from the two units. When the capacitor potential reaches a predetermined positive or negative value an output can be obtained.

In any case, the result will be that there is a correction of the volume, and hence the weight, of the article 19 only when the number of articles showing excessive deviation of weight in one 10 sense exceeds the number of articles showing excessive deviation in the opposite sense.

In a further embodiment of the invention now to be described two further advantageous fea tures are involved: in the first place the limits of wei ht deviation at which rejection occurs are made different from those at which deviation has reached a significant value, and secondly the eilect of later weighing is made of more importance than earli r weighings.

In this embodiment of the invention use can be made of the s" e moulding machine 50, conveyor and gui e 59 as shown in Figure 1. A weighing scale similar to that of Figure 2 is employed, and circuit means as in Figure 3 are used for releasing the balance arm after a predetermined interval, and for relocking it after a further interval. For this purpose tubes V1 and V2 only are necessary, in conjunction with the photocell system operating contacts PCI. Moreover, the contacts 35 and 37 of the weighing scale are not. mad use of, but in their place a photoelectric system is employed.

This is shown in Figure 5. An optical system Hi9 is provided for proiecting a beam of light onto a polished fiat surface or mirror iii! moving with the scale arm i i and the reflected beam of light falls upon one of a series of four photocells B2, 593, its, 85. These photocells are set up at po nts which correspond respectively to upper and lower rejection limits and two intermediate po nts correspond ng to the intermediate l mits at which there is no reiection but at which the corre tion eiifect is reouired. The absolute value or these levels can be adjusted by moving the series of nhotocel s towards or away from the m rror or relatively to each other.

Each of the photocells is associated with an electrical circu t, sho n in Figure 6, the circuit for ea ch photocell being sim lar. In each circuit the photoce l is connected in series with a high res stance- Rm acrrss the terminals ii of a suitable source of high tension p ate current, and the vo tage a pearin across the cell is applied to the grid cathode input circ it of a tr ode tu e V10, conveniently the first tube of a double triole V10, V11. The cathode of t e tube V10 is connected to a variable potential divider R11. R12 a so across the plate su ply. so that the grid of the tub is ne ativel b ased with res ect to the cathode. It is preferable that the plate supply used, is stabilised by means of a resistor R 3 discharge tube V12 of known type. The plate of tube V10 is provided with a load resistor R14 and a coupling resistor R15 is connected between this plate and the grid of the tube V11. The cathode of tube v1 is returned to the positive terminal Of the plate supply and the plate of the second tube is connected through a rela M to the unstabi ised plate su ply, The photocell used is of the barrier layer type and briefly, the effect of the circuit is that when light fa ls noon the photocell, there is a very rapid and definite operation of the relay M nc uded in the plate of the tube V11.

There are four units such as that shown in Figure 6, each with a relay corresponding to relay M the individual relays can be identified as ML and ME, which will operate respectively if the article is light or heavy, and MXL and MXi-l' which will operate if the article exceeds the light or heavy rejection limits r spectively.

It is important that if the balance arm should oscillate, so that say, cell is; is first illuminated, followed by cell 535, only the correspondi g o the first illuminated cell should operate.

2,66%5 s t-i For reason, in each unit as shown in" Figurethe one unit is included in the circuit of the M relay'oi the other. In this way once th M relay of one unit of a pair operated the circuit of the re of the other unit is open circuite'd. Contacts, such as Ma r the various l/l relays can he used to operate electromechanical counters i l The relays rejection device p ovidecl wi-h changeover contacts Nil-hand lvlLz, shown. in ure 7. Th back contacts MH2, that is to ay, those which are closed when light does not ia-ll'upon the photocell, are used to connect a small capacitor G10 to a source of positive stabills-ed volt-age, of th order of 160 volts, through a resistor- R23 for each set of contacts; When relay operated, contacts change over and the now charged capacitor G10 is connected in. parallel with a substantially larger capacitor G11 to vary the charge maintained in that capacitor.

Back contacts Min of relay ML are likewise ar- 3 l and ldXliassociated with the two outermostphotocells have contacts MXEIzand M25112 w :ch are used to operate the The relays Mill and 'associated wi h the two inner cells Iil l andlilli areranged to connect a small'capacitor Giz'thrcugh a resistor R21 to a voltage source, but in this case the voltage negative.

Hence, when relay operates capacitor G12 is connected in parallel with capacitor G11 and depending on the charge 1 on it that instant w1li reduce its charge if it is positive, and make it negative, or more negative,

ii'it'is uncharged or negatively charged. Small current limiting resistors R25; and R22 are included in the circuits of capacitors G10 and G12. Capacitor G11 therefore acts as an integrating device and at any moment its charge will. represent the summed eiie'ct oi the previous actuations of the relays. It is arranged, however, that the efiect of earlier weighings is gradually cancelled with time. This is doneby connecting across the larger capacitor a variable resistance network R24, R25

so that the charge on the capacitor G11 isgradually leaking away. The time constant is made appropriate to the rate ofweighings,- so that at any moment the integrated charge corresponds to a substantial number of weighings.

The larger capacitor is connected in the inputs to two parallel channels. The first channel'comprises a cathode follower stage coupled to an amplitude limiter.

The cathode follower stage comprises triode tube V12 having cathode load resistor R26, direct coupled over resistor R21 to triode tube V13. The control grid of tube V13 is returned to a point of positive potential through high valve resistors R28, R29. and the cathode of the tube is returned to a point of somewhat less positive potential. The plate circuit of tube Vii includes relay 22/3, and the plate can be connected to ground through relay contacts H1 and S1. Nor rally, with capaci-' tor G11 discharged tube V1: is out off, and relay H/B unoperated.

The second channel is generally similar to the first except that it includes a phase inverter stage; the channel comprises triode cathode follower tube V14, with cathode resistor R10 returned to a point of negative potential, coupling resistor R31 to phase inverter tube V15. Tube V1 cathode ML/3 is similar.

is returned to a point on potential divider-resistor- R32 and the plate circuit includes load resistor Rag-and is coupled to tube V16 over resistor R34. Tube v13 has its cathode L/3. The plate circuit can be shunted. by relay contacts L1 and S1;

Normally both tubes V13 and V16 are out ofibut if the charge on capacitor G11 reaches a certain level after a predetermined number of actuations of relay Mil/3 within a given time interval, tube V13 passes current, relay E/B operates and by its contact H1 locks in. v The operation of, relay L/S'in'theeventcf a series of actuations oirelay I A valve voltmeter i ll ofthes center zerotypeca-n lee-connected in parallel with capacitor Girtogive an indication atany moment of the statistical weight'deviation. Itwillbe ap preciatedthat the-relative capacitances oicapaci tors G and G12, and G11 will determine the norm her of weighings necessary to produce actuation of relays H/S or-L/Elyresistor B25, in conjunction with capacitor G11 willcontrol the memory-'- time.

'If' relay Elm-operates a correction circuit is prepared over contacts GT1, L2 and H2, Figure 8,"

to control unit "it, which in this case need be no more than a relief relay controlling the correction motor 53'. At this time, however, contacts GT1 are open, and no correctiontakes place. Similarly, if relay L73 operates a correction cir-' cult is'prepared over contacts GT1, Hrand L2, to

control unit if, for causing the motor to run in the reverse direction;

takes place.

When either relay 1-1/3 01' L/S operates, a timing and resetting circuit is operated. This includes a relay z/zjcontacts H: are arranged normally to charge-positively through resistor R40 a capaci tor G20, and contacts L1 similarly charge a capacitor G21. When contacts L2 or E3 changeover;

capacitor G or G21 is connected to relay Z72 and the capacitor charge is su'fiicient to cause momentary actuation of the relay. Thereupon, contacts Z1 close to discharge through resistor R, the main-capacitor G11, to restart theintegrating process.

Contacts Z2 are associated with'a timing tube V20, which is'similar to the timing circuits shown in Figure 3. Tube -V20 has a cathode resistor H41 in series with a relay CT/ii. The grid includes a. resistor R42. A capacitor G22 is connected to the grid of tube V20 over contacts GT2,

but can be discharged over the back contacts GT2 through resistor R43 when relay (IT/f5 is oper-' ated; Contacts Z2 shunt the grid circuit oi tube V20, through resistor R44.

Tube V20 is normally passing current, and relay CT/ii is operated; capacitor G22 is connected to the grid of tube V20.

Whenrelay 2/2 operates, as

contacts Z2 close momentarily andcause the grid of valve'V2o to become morenegative; the plate current drops, and relay (IT/ 5, normally oper ated, releases. Capacitor G22 is connected to the grid of tube V20, and the plate current of the tube rises slowly.

across a relay- 8/ l isconnectcd to a point or posireturned to a. point of positive potential, and in its plate circuit is relay Indicator lamps i 52 and H3 can'be employed to show when'correctioncircuit" described above,

tive potential through resistor R45, and begins to charge up.

The correction motor runs for only a short time, since it is better to correct in small steps, so as to avoid any tendency to over-correction. Hence, the time constant of timing circuit tube V20 is made quite short but can be adjusted by R42. Relay (ET/3 therefore operates again; contacts GT1 open the correction circuit; contacts 0T2 changeover and discharge capacitor G22 and contacts CT; cause relay S/l to operate momentarily. Contacts S1 open in the hold circuit of relay H/% or L/3 and restore the circuits to normal.

It is not necessary that an integrating device of the kind described should be used, and it is possible to use a digital type of corr ction circuit--that it to say one in which a digital register is set up for the indicated value of the deviations, means being provided to cancel the efiect of weighings which have taken place a predetermined number of weighings in advance or a predetermined time in advance of the preset discrimination conditions.

We claim:

1. In an apparatus for manufacturing articles having a characteristic nominally constant value from article to article, testing means responsive to the value of the said characteristic of an article for producing a first response function when said value exceeds a predetermined limit, and a second response function when said value falls below a predetermined limit, conveyor means for conveying articles in s ccession to said testing means and means for discharging said articles from said 0 testing means after testing, a control unit for responding to successive response functions produced on successive tastings, said control unit including an integrating device responding differentially to said first second response functions, controlled by said integrating device for producing an output when the number of. the one exceeds the number of the other to a predetermined extent and means for decreasing with the passage of time the response of said integrating device.

2. In an apparatus for manufacturing articles having a characteristic of nominally constant value from article to article, tee ing means for automatically testing said articles in succession in respect of said characteristic and for determining if the deviation of the value of said characteristic from the nominal value is excessively positive or excessively negative, a registering device coupled to said testing means for registering difierentially the numbers of said exces ive positive and negative deviations, control means coupled to said registering device for producing a control function when the differential between said numbers exceeds a predetermined amount, and means for decreasing with the passage of time the number registered by said registering device.

3. In an apparatus for manufacturing articles having a characteristic of nominally constant value from article to article, testing means for automatically testirn said articles in succession respect of said characteristic, and for determining if the deviation of the value or" said characteristic from the nominal value is excessively positive or excessively negative, a first capacitor, a second capacitor and a third capacitor, switch means operated by said testing means to connect said first capacitor to said third capacitor to vary the charge on said third capacitor in one sense when an excessively positive deviation occurs, switch means operated by said testing means to connect said second capacitor to said third capacitor to vary the charge on said thi capacitor in the opposite sense when an exc iv ly positive deviation occurs, and voltage-r pensive means connected to said third capacit 4. An apparatus as claimed in cl and comprising conveyor means for prose ng articles to said testing means at roughly regular intervals, and means for discharging said third capacitor in a time substantially greater than one of said intervals.

5. An apparatus as claimed in claim 4, wherein said discharging means is continuously connected to said capacitor.

6. In an apparatus for manufacturin articles having a characteristic of nominally constant value from article to article, testing means for automatically testing said articles :1 succession in respect of said characteristic, and for determining if the deviation of the value of said characteristic from the nominal value is excessively positive or excessively negative, a registering device, registering means operated by said testing means for increasing in a positive sense the quantity registered by said device when an excessively positive deviation occurs and for inc "casing in a negative sense the quantity registered by device when an exces ively negative deviation occurs, a positive limiting means responding to the quantity registered by said device when the quantity attains a predetermined positive value, a negative limiting means responding to the quantity registered by said device when the quantity attains a predetermined negative value, and means for reducing with the passage of time the quantity registered by said device.

7. In an apparatus for manufacturing articl s having a characteristic of nominally constant value from article to article, testing means for automatically testing said articles in succession in respect of said characteristic, and for determining if the deviation of the value of said characteristic from the nominal value is excessively positive or excessively negative, a regi tering device, registering means operated by testing means for increasing in a positive sense the cuantity registered by said device when an exec sively positive deviation occurs and for increasr in a negative sense the quantity registered by said device when an excessively negative deviation occurs, a positive limiting means re ponding to the quantity registered by said device when the quantity attains a predetermined positive value, a negative limiting means responding to the quantity registered by said device when the quantity attains a predetermined negative value, said test ing means being arranged to detect the said ex cessive positive and negative deviations and in addition at least one further and more excessive deviation, a rejection means for rejecting articles, and operating means for operation of said rejection means when said testing means detects said more excessive deviation.

8. In an apparatus for manufacturing articles having a characteristic of nominally constant value from article to article, testing means for automatically testing said articles in succession in respect of said characteristic and for determining if the deviation of the value of said characteristic from the nominal value is excessively positive or excessively negative, a registering device coupled to-isaid testing means for registering differentially;

bers exceeds a predetermined amount, and means for decreasing with the passage of time the mun ber registered by said registering device.

JOHN ADOLPI-I SARGROVE.

Refereneesfiited intherfilerof. thispatent e UNITED STATES PATENTS Number Name- Date Meore Dec. 4, 1934 Umansky Aug. 11, 1936 Molins et a1 Mar. 7, 194a Zieboiz Apr. 23, 1948 Sunstein July 26, 1949 Burn Sept. 20, 19 .9 Koechel June 12, 1951 Parsons July 29, 1952 

